• Friday, August 28 2015
  • JSE Sens

What next for Motlanthe?

by Stephen Grootes, December 19 2012, 16:01
  • Kindle
  • submit to reddit
Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe. Picture: PUXLEY MAKGATHO
Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe. Picture: PUXLEY MAKGATHO

AFTER the election of President Jacob Zuma for another term as ANC leader, the person who lost that contest, Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe, now has to consider his own short-term political future.

By Tuesday evening, rumours were already circulating that Motlanthe was preparing to leave his government office "immediately". While those have not turned out to be true, they are a real indication that there is speculation he may feel his position is untenable. While he determines his course of action, there are several issues that could weigh on his decision.

For him to leave government office now could lay him open to criticism that he is behaving in a petulant manner. It can be argued that because he was appointed as deputy president by the leader of the ANC, the organisation he still belongs to, he has a duty to see out his full term. Thus, by stepping down, he would show disrespect to Zuma, and thus to the ANC.

Also, as a loyal ANC cadre, Motlanthe has a duty to ensure that the party appears unified to the nation, following the Mangaung leadership contest. If he left, it would appear that there were divisions. He could also be accused of trying to force the ANC to again live through the drama of losing a deputy president half-way through his term (the first being Zuma himself, who was "relieved of his duties by Thabo Mbeki after the trial of Schabir Shaik).

It could even be that Motlanthe is trying to force an "Mbeki recall" type of scenario, which would plunge the ANC, and the country, into another period of uncertainty.

Motlanthe may also believe that as he is now unlikely to serve in a top public office again, he might as well make the most of it and enjoy the power, and perks, of office until the 2014 elections.

However, several problems may arise, should he stay on.

First, he does not appear to have political legitimacy at the moment. He holds no position in the ANC apart from "member" and "deployed cadre", as he did not make himself available for nomination to the national executive committee. This means he has no political power in the party itself and no voice in the party's upper echelons.

Motlanthe could therefore find himself ordered to implement policies and decisions in government, while having no say in the making of those decisions or policies.

To make matters worse, should Zuma want to take revenge after the ANC leadership race, the president could make Motlanthe’s life difficult in all sorts of ways.

The first would be to make him responsible for difficult and complex problems, while giving him no power to actually solve them. A primary example of this is the decision by the Cabinet, chaired by Zuma, to place Motlanthe in charge of the Gauteng highways ministerial Committee. This means Motlanthe has to find a solution to the highly contentious e-tolling programme for Gauteng's freeways.

Motlanthe could find himself being handed many other such problems over the next few months, should he decide to stay on.

Should the Zuma government become embroiled in new controversies, Motlanthe could find his legacy tarred by them, with no say in how they are resolved. At the same time, should some fresh scandal erupt with which he cannot live, to resign while the Zuma administration is under pressure could send a very different political message.

But Motlanthe appears to want to be seen as a loyal ANC member. This might be the argument that would persuade him to stay on.

• Grootes is an Eyewitness News reporter


Login OR Join up TO COMMENT


Kgalema Motlanthe is the man who might have been but never was. Don't feel sorry for him. Feel sorry for yourself and for South Africa. This is the man who could have stopped Zuma, who SHOULD have stopped Zuma. But, in the end he didn't. He dithered and waited, hedged his bets and said nothing. Then it was too late and he was crushed in a landslide: Mr Nice Guy. Mr Sitting on the Fence. Mr Indecision. Mr Bland. Today you'll be told how he showed courage at Mangaung and stuck to principle; how he sacrificed his political career for the sake of principle. But he didn't. In the end he dithered too much, let Zuma get away with too much for too long without speaking out. And, when it was all too late he tried to make a stand. But he was finished too. There is a great lesson here. Never ever refrain from speaking out, from standing up and from taking action when bad things are said or done in the name of the common good. Always speak up for truth and justice and right and wrong. Because if you don't, you will be swept away by the tide of the populist mob and the rabble. And your name will no longer stand for anything of value and your integrity will vanish in the wind.

Dec 19, 2012 5:0 | 0 replies


Grootes, one of SA's most astute commentators, sees Motlanthe having "no political power in the party itself and no voice in the party's upper echelons" as lacking political legitimacy and an impediment to his functioning as deputy president. This shows the lack of separation between Party and State and the New-ANC's hostility to the Constitution. It has always regarded "segregation of duties" - one of the key checks and balances in a constitutional democracy - as "two centres of power" and undesirable and against its centralising tendencies. Put differently, if Motlanthe is miffed, can he be relied upon to serve the country even if he is not serving the New-ANC - can he be relied upon to be a "LOYAL strategically deployed cadre"? /// The implications of Grootes' speculation that J783 may make Motlanthe "responsible for difficult and complex problems, while giving him no power to actually solve them" is that J783 is prepared to commit treason for the sake of his stay-out-of-jail programme. A not unreasonable surmise, based upon his track record.

Dec 20, 2012 10:20 | 0 replies
  • All Share : 49653.59
    Change: 1.08%
    Top 40 : 44108.64
    Change: 1.11%
    Financial 15 : 16340.16
    Change: 0.67%
    Industrial 25 : 63624.32
    Change: 0.92%
    Resource 10 : 35901.43
    Change: 3.01%
    All data is delayed by 15 min
    Data supplied by Profile Data
  • FTSE 100 : 6192.03
    Change: 3.56%
    Dow Jones Industrial : 16654.77
    Change: 2.27%
    All Share : 49644.69
    Change: 1.06%
    ASX All Ordinaries : 5274.7
    Change: 0.00%
    S&P 500 index : 1987.66
    Change: 2.43%
    All data is delayed by 15 min
    Data supplied by Profile Data
  • ZAR/USD : 13.1571
    Change: 0.14%
    ZAR/GBP : 20.2401
    Change: 0.19%
    ZAR/EUR : 14.8138
    Change: 0.32%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.1082
    Change: 0.28%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.434
    Change: 0.28%
    All data is delayed by 15 min
    Data supplied by Profile Data
  • N/A : 1129.93
    Change: 0.36%
    Platinum US$/oz : 1005.63
    Change: 0.22%
    Silver US$/oz : 14.51
    Change: -0.21%
    Palladium US$/oz : 576
    Change: 1.77%
    Brent Crude : 47.76
    Change: 0.61%
    All data is delayed by 15 min
    Data supplied by Profile Data